I can’t believe how bad the writing is. This is like someone deciding to make a porno, jerking off on the lens, and thinking they’ve made a masterpiece. I can only assume the editor started working on this and got about four pages in and just gave the eff up.
Okay, I’m getting ahead of myself.
The preface done, the book opens up and we’re in the head of a seventeen year old Bella in a car on her way to the Phoenix airport to fly to Forks, Washington. The Chapter is entitled “First Sight.” This is presumably in reference to her meeting Edward Cullen.
Here’s a brief synopsis of Chapter one before I give you my thoughts thus far.
Chapter one sees our “heroine” moving from Phoenix to Washington because of some reason we’re not given yet. Her mother apparently fled her husband (the Chief of the Forks police) to Phoenix when Bella was young, and despite that Bella has been spending summers in Forks for quite some time. Her dad, whom she calls “Charlie” gives her a beat up old pickup as a present, and she goes to her first day of school. She bounces from class to class meeting new people when, as she is eating her first lunch in the cafeteria, looks across the room to see a group of pale, sullen, beautiful students sitting in a corner and not eating. She’s immediately smitten with one in particular, Edward, whom she ends up sitting next to in Biology class where he looks at her with such hatred and contempt that by the end of the day she’s ready to cry.
There… that’s the nuts of Chapter one.
Reading the first chapter of this book felt a lot like reading a first draft fiction piece written by a tenth grader. I’m lucky this was an eReader and not a physical copy because I would have been tempted to red pen the fuck out of the margins with questions. I want to tackle this as completely as possible, so I’m going to proceed in a linear fashion, using quotes as examples of my confusion and consternation.
Here’s where things start to go downhill for me. The sixth sentence of chapter one says, “It rains on on this inconsequential town more than any other place in the United States of America.” Now, first of all, that’s not factual, but that’s not what bugs me here. This sentence is tied to a paragraph that basically says Forks is a horrible, sullen, depressing place that no person in their right mind should live. This is furthered two sentences later when she says, “It was from this town and its gloomy, omnipresent shade that my mother escaped with me when I was only a few months old.” The language here is important for setting up the town. Her mother escaped, implying the town itself was confinement. She didn’t say her mother escaped her father, or the marriage, she’s talking about the town and tying that sentiment to Forks.
Then shit gets strange: “It was to Forks that I now exiled myself - an action I took with great horror. I detested Forks.” Okay, I know you hate Forks. You just spent an entire paragraph telling me how awful it was. And WHY ARE YOU MOVING THERE? Why would ANY SEVENTEEN YEAR OLD GIRL voluntarily change high schools, inviting the scorn of being the “new kid,” and move to a town she hates. I’m guessing that question gets answered for me at some point, but as it stands now I want to punch Bella in the face. Repeatedly. I want to strap her to a table in a room sheathed in plastic and adorned with pages from the first chapter before I get her to admit General Zod floating through space had more depth than her before I plunge a very large knife into her chest. (The new season of Dexter just started filming btw, and Julia Styles and Jonny Lee Miller have joined for season 5!) This game of “I hope she explains this at some point” continues when Bella says regarding her decision to move; “I knew [My Father] was more than a little confused by my decision - like my mother before me, I hadn’t made a secret of my distaste for Forks” …and then…. NOTHING. How about one fucking sentence that references or makes implication of whatever the reason is that she’s moving. Some fucking foreshadowing would be nice. Why give me a character who clearly has motivations then not even hint at what is motivating her? Who is this Bella girl? Why is she out heroine? Why should we care? There are no answers in Chapter one. I’m hoping for more out of Chapter two.
Continuing on; Bella arrives in her town and is picked up by Charlie her dad… whom she calls Charlie… which implies they are not close nor have they been close. Except she’s spent every summer with him since she can remember. Oh, and he has all of her school pictures in his house. Oh, and she’s FUCKING MOVING IN WITH HIM. The author is trying to make this relationship not matter, but in doing so makes me wonder why Bella is so emotionally vapid. Her father can’t be an abusive dude, as what teenager volunteers for that? So, what’s the deal here. Again, hoping this pans out down the road.
Charlie picks her up at the airport and there’s awkward small talk and Charlie tells Bella he bought her a car, which ends up being a 50’s era truck. This is one of those things that seems like its foreshadowing something down the line, and maybe it is, but it mostly feels like it’s just writing to fill the page. The truck is given character and if that character comes into play later great, but if it ends up just being her ride throughout the book this is just taking up space.
So, they get back to her house and she sets up shop in her childhood bedroom. This sequence ends with this bit, “It was nice to be alone, not to have to smile and look pleased; a relief to stare dejectedly out the window at the sheeting rain and let just a few tears escape. I wasn’t in the mood to go on a real crying jag. I would save that for bedtime, when I would have to think about the coming morning.”
Oh for fuck’s sake I want to punch her in the throat. Here we have a girl, who made the conscious decision to uproot her life and move to a place she hates and now she’s crying about it. Are you fucking kidding me? If the reason she left Phoenix doesn’t turn out to be a pregnancy gone wrong, a date rape, or some other tragedy (maybe she’s an illegal alien fleeing the new immigration law! See… I’m angry AND topical). So she’s resolute in her decision to move to her own personal hell, and yet she’s crying about being there. I hate her so much.
It’s shortly after that we get out first physical description of Bella. She’s an ivory skinned, slender but not toned brunette. She talks about how she’ll never fit in, blah blah blah - bottom line, she’s an average looking girl… which, according to her tone and demeanor (“Facing my pallid reflection in the mirror…”) isn’t good enough. Since she’s not a supermodel, she’s ugly. Strongest literary heroine ever! That’s right girls, if you’re not hot, you’re fugly. Now go to bed and cry about it…
And after she cries, but before she falls asleep she says, “I didn’t relate well to people, period. Even my Mother, who I was closer to than anyone else on this planet, was never in harmony with me.”
Not to beat a dead horse here, but if she was the person you were closest to on the planet why did you leave?
Okay, finally in Chapter one we get Bella’s first day at her new high school. Reading this story literally made me throw my hands up a couple of times in the international sign for WTF. Every other paragraph contradicts the construct of Bella’s character. She says she’s shy, then she’s chatting it up with a stranger in the hallway. She AGAIN says she’s shy, then she’s having lunch with seven strangers at lunch. So, is she shy? Because it seems she has a fairly easy time meeting people and making friends. I’M CONFUSED STEPHANIE MEYER. Most of the first day of school is Bella feeling self-conscious and displaced in a sea of fresh teenager, while contradicting herself and not even mentioning in her thoughts to us, the readers, what the FUCK SHE IS DOING THERE.
Then it happens… we’re in chapter one and the book jumps the shark. Sitting in the Cafeteria chatting with seven strangers, she looks across the room and sees a group that doesn’t seem to belong. Five people, all varying degrees of being reschlongulously hot. The last was, “lanky, less bulky, with untidy, bronze-colored hair.”
And thus, we get our first glimpse at Edward, and his hair.
He sits with a group described as beautiful, pale, and inhuman NOT eating their food on their trays, and everyone in this school seems to not care. Huh? Da fuck? Oh sure, every high school has it’s cliques, however my high school didn’t have the “looks like they could be in college or teachers“, “devastatingly, inhumanly beautiful“, “chalky pale“, with “dark shadows under their eyes [...] as if they were all suffering from a sleepness night“. Are you effing kidding me? These people just hang out in the cafeteria with a tray of food they’re not eating, trying to not look conspicuous, and that works?
Dear Ms. Meyer,
I am not a fucking idiot.
Sincerly,
Merlin
We’re told all five of them live together and that they moved a couple of years back from Alaska, and they’re all adopted. Then, with all the subtlety of a prison shower rape, Meyer draws our line of connection between Bella and this odd group. “I felt a surge of pity, and relief. Pity because, as beautiful as they were, they were outsiders, clearly not accepted. Relief that i wasn’t the only newcomer here, and certainly no the most interesting by any standard.”
The curtain closes on this first glimpse when Edward looks up and meets Bella’s gaze with “some kind of unmet expectation.”
“Which is the boy with the reddish brown hair?” Okay, we get it. You noticed his coif. “he was still staring at me, but not gawking like the other students had today - had had a slightly frustrated expression.”
Sixth period is biology (metaphor?) and Bella gets put in the only empty desk, RIGHT NEXT TO EDWARD CULLEN, the dark and steamy one. “Next to the center aisle, I recognized Edward Cullen by his unusual hair.” Okay, seriously. Enough with the hair. You didn’t notice it was him because he’s un-fucking-dead? Maybe the fact that he’s pale, or graceful, or any of the other thesaurus orgy adjectives you used… but again with the hair?
Here’s where it gets weird. The entirety of the class is spent with Edward basically giving Bella the stare of doom while she waits for him to unclench his fist. Yes, that’s it. “The class seemed to drag on longer than the others. Was it because the day was finally coming to a close, or because I was waiting for his tight fist to loosen?”
What’s up with Edward giving Bella the stink eye? “He was glaring down at me again, his black eyes full of revulsion.” I’m sure we’re going to get a little Sam and Diane animosity before they ultimately come together. I’m sure of this because it’s so morbidly cliche that Meyer can’t resist.
And apparently his look is so powerful that it set’s Bella off. She is so angry she about to cry! During the walk to the next class we meet Mike, who introduces himself to Bella in hopes that he can eventually hit that shit. He asks her why Edward was so weird in class, and she’s intrigued why his behavior was seemingly so odd.
After all her classes are done she heads to the office for a bit of paperwork and there’s Edward talking to the school administrator trying to get transferred out of Biology class. Bella assumes it’s all about her. The best part about this are these two sentences:
“He was arguing in a low, attractive voice.”
“‘Never mind, then’ he said hastily in a voice like velvet.”
This is so blatantly heavy handed that I again feel the need to reach into the book and slap her. The insinuation here is that his attractiveness actually trumps the fact he’s an asshole. I love it! This book is so on the top of my ‘important life lessons for girls’ list.
When Edward realizes she’s there he leaves she turns in her paperwork and ends up in her car trying not to cry…. because the most attractive dude in school seemingly doesn’t like her on the first day.
So, there it is. Chapter one. Bella is already the worst type of girl. If Meyer was trying to establish her heroine as a whiny, weak, weepy, stupid girl easily swayed by an attractive man… mission accomplished.
Oh, did I mention his hair?